
Introduction
Casshern may not mean too much to the average man in the street, especially in the UK, but he’s definitely an item of pop culture in Japan, up there with any of the Marvel Comic characters. The creator, Tatsuo Yoshida isn’t a name that will ring too many bells here either, but he’s the man who also created Speed Racer, and Gatchaman, better known in the West as Battle of the Planets. So you can see why Casshern was ripe for a live action adaptation back in 2004, over 30 years after he first appeared in anime form. 2004 was also the year of the digital back lot, that brief flirtation with egregious CGI used in filmmaking that was thankfully short-lived. The US gave us Revenge of the Sith, Sin City, and Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, and Europe gave us Immortel. Stand your actors in front of a green screen, give them a rough idea of what they are supposed to do, and then colour in the backgrounds afterwards, and audiences can marvel at characters that don’t interact with anything. It’s a useful filmmaking tool, but you really shouldn’t make a whole movie that way. But no one knew that back in 2004, which is why Japan gave us Casshern, essentially real life actors inserted into a 3D anime.
In the future, following a protracted and devastating war between East and West, peace finally reigns when the Eastern Federation wins. But this is no glorious peace, for the war has wrought havoc on the world, pollution and decay now permeates everything, and far from ending the fighting, now the government has to face terrorism as well. Humanity is tired, dispirited, and dying, for the pollution takes its toll, and mutations weaken the gene pool. One man has hope, Dr Azuma’s neo-cell treatment offers life instead of death, and he hopes to heal his stricken wife when the technology is developed. As so often happens, the only faction willing to support his work is the military. He has his own problems when his son Tetsuya refuses to follow him into medicine, and instead joins the military to make his mark, before coming back to marry his childhood sweetheart Luna. But tragedy strikes when Tetsuya is killed. Worse, Dr Azuma’s experiments go horribly wrong, creating a new life form, the Neoroids, who are intent on exterminating their creators, and who kidnap Azuma’s wife. His only hope is to use the neo-cell treatment to resurrect his fallen son, and transform him into the hero Casshern.
Picture
Momentum Asia gives us Casshern’s 2.35:1 picture in the anamorphic format, although it is one of those pesky NTSC-PAL standards conversions. It isn’t that bad, with ghosting and the like at a minimum. There is a smidgen of interlacing, and they seem to have gotten around the innate softness with a touch of edge enhancement. Otherwise, Casshern is clear and sharp throughout, and as for the colours, I think they invented a couple of new ones for this movie. Casshern is bright, it’s hyper-real, it’s as if they threw everything at the screen and hoped that some of it would stick. There’s a mish-mash of styles in the filming, with stark monochrome for the flashback war sequences, brilliant colours for the present day, moments of intense clarity, scenes saturated with deliberate grain, different colour schemes, different lighting effects… The same goes for the production design, which mixes the post-apocalyptic with the post-industrial, throws some art deco at the screen, maybe some steampunk. It is a visual menagerie that really needed someone to just put their foot down and say ‘pick one’. And I thought the lens flare on the recent Star Trek movie was bad… Yeesh!
Sound
No choices here, just a DD 5.1 Japanese surround track, with English subtitles. You can’t select the subtitles from the menu, and the only way to turn them on and off is directly with your remote control. The dialogue is clear and the surround is vibrant and effective in conveying the film’s many action sequences.
I was really looking forward to your review of this movie. For me it had the opposite effect than it appears to have had on you. I had very low expectations and was bowled away by the visual beauty of the whole piece. Yes - it's all a bit like en extended pop video but, wow! what a video!! And with so little funding. Stylistically I thought it was superbly realised. It had a very sharply defined look and feel and seemed to stay 'on brand' throughout. I agree the narrative was a bit lost but no more so than most super-hero movies. I thought it was a breath-takingly BIG film and every frame looked good enough to frame and display. So there we have it...your 'pretentious tosh' is my poetry on this occasion. I wonder what Si / Mark O think. I seem to recall that they all went for the 'Play' special on this?
By all accounts, Casshern is a true marmite movie. Every opinion I have read seems to polarise into love or hate, with little middle ground. The curious thing is that both sides usually acknowledge that the film has flaws, and even accept that they are the same flaws for both sides. I think it's all about preconceptions and expectations. This is definitely a movie that deserves a second, or even third opinion. I hope you can find the time to review it as well, Stuart.
Yes - As soon as I clear the backlog I'll rewatch it. I hope I enjoy it as much second time through. I've recommended films I've enjoyed in the past and then watched them as if through the eyes of the person I recommended them to and sometimes see them as if the rose tinted specs have been well and truly knocked off! I haven't read many reviews though I seem to recall the comments on Amazon were a bit harsh for this film. I caught it afterits initial release so probably after the hype too. I think it was marketed as a 'Matrix' style movie and therefore disappointed those looking for a repeat of that. (I think there was just one brief fighting scene that could compare and it was this that was glommed upon and shown in trailers etc).
It was a great review though Jits (as per) ... even if I don't agree with your conclusions! I must say this is unusual as I tend to like all the anime that you recommend and tend to agree with your opinions in the majority of the films / series that I have seen.
Was it the (lack of) narrative that you least liked? Or the ponderous poetics?
Do you agree that it looked fantastic for a low budget movie?
I love the quote on the DVD cover, 'Better than the Matrix sequels combined', which I consider damning with faint praise.
I do agree that the film looked beautiful at times, but I also felt that the visuals were at times overwhelming. It's one reason why I think that Casshern may have worked better as an out and out silent movie. There were many things that disappointed me about the film, the singleminded focus on 'the message', the lack of narrative, the questionable continuity, the thin charactreisations, the sheer convenience of the script
SPOILER:
The neoroids winding up in an abandoned secret base full of warrior robots
But above all, what I thought was missing was a sense of fun.